Take the one with a long neck and a small bulb. The seed cavity is only in the bulb and the neck is solid flesh, so for the same weight and the same price a long-necked squash gives you noticeably more to cook and less to scoop out. Then press a thumbnail into the rind: on a mature squash it should not dent.
What to check
👁️
Lookeven, deep beige all over. Green streaks or a green cast under the tan mean it was cut immature, and those cook up watery and bland. Gloss on its own tells you little, since store squash is often washed and polished.
🤲
Feelheavy for its size and hard all over, with no soft or damp spots, especially at the two ends.
📦
Check the boxa dry, corky stem about an inch long. A green stem means immature, and a missing stem leaves an opening for rot. Do not pick a squash up by the stem either. It looks like a handle and it is not one, and a snapped stem is exactly how the next person gets a rotting squash.
📝
Notea butternut is usually better a few weeks after harvest than the day it was cut, because starch converts to sugar while it cures. Squash that has been in storage a month is a better buy, not a worse one.
Common mistakeputting a whole squash in the fridge. Uncut, it holds 2 to 3 months somewhere cool and dry, around 50 to 55F. Colder than that and it takes chilling damage, which is the real reason the fridge is wrong. Once you cut it, then it belongs in the fridge.
If they are not perfect: a nicked, scuffed or soft-spotted rind is fine if you are cooking it this week, because the rind is the entire storage system. Pre-cut squash in a tray has more cut surface than almost anything else sold, so use it within two or three days and expect less flavor. That is a fair trade for the convenience, as long as you know you are making it.
Written by the team behind RIPE, a free app that reads a photo of the whole produce pile and rings the ripest ones. Every cue above is one you can check with your own hands, and it all works with no app at all.
Now on Google Play
The whole bin, in one photo.
You just read the cue for one piece. RIPE reads a photo of the entire display, draws numbered rings on the ones worth taking, and tells you why in the same plain words these guides use. Then it remembers what you brought home and nudges you before it turns.
It claims only what a camera can actually see. Every verdict ends by handing the last check back to your hands, which is the part these guides just taught you.
$19 a year, locked
For people who found us before launch. That price stays yours for as long as you keep it, not just the first year.
Get RIPE on Google Play
Nothing is charged now and no card is taken here. We email you one link at launch
and $19 a year is held for you, for good. No weekly billing, and no trial that
charges you the moment you forget about it.